Our Food
Good Fellos specializes in Italian Cuisine and our famous scratch-made Brick Oven Pizzas, prepared by our talented staff. Savor every bite while you enjoy one of our 16 local and craft beers on tap or choose a special wine from our extensive 50 bottle list. Top off your experience with our delicious selection of desserts - all made from scratch in house!
If you're looking for something unique, be sure to check our "Specials" chalkboard and ask your friendly server about our menu items. Our ingredients are locally sourced whenever possible, fresh, and hand-selected to provide our guests with the finest quality and taste.
Call Us: 315 646-3463
Our Wines & Drinks
Wine Night
Wednesday 4:00 PM
The Original local wine night! Enjoy our house wines, only $2 a glass or $8 a bottle. Our prices have remained the same for a dozen years. Come enjoy our cozy fun atmosphere and bring your friends.
Choose from one of 50 hand-selected bottles of wine on the wine menu at our cozy, full service bar, or from one of the 16 local or regional microbreweries on tap.
If you are in the mood for something new, our friendly, knowledgeable staff is always ready to help you pair your wine with your entree or will suggest one of our signature cocktails for you to try.
Every Wednesday we have the best cure for the mid-week blues with our popular Wine Night starting at 4 pm, featuring $2 glasses of wine!
Wine and Beer Bottle Specials to Compliment Food Orders Available!
Christmas Time at Good Fellos
What Our Clients Say
Testimonials
Amazing food.
All of it!
Don’t ask should we…
You definitely should!
Now!
Buon Appetito β€
Alan Bartnik
Had a great meal with the proper social distancing protocols In place. The servers were top notch!!!
Jon Macy
Pizzas are the best on my area and the service is excellent… very friendly personal! With a good selection of local wines!
Lily Barrientos
Great food. Coming from the Central/North NJ area near NYC that’s a big complement. You’ll find a good selection of foods where everything is up to snuff. Great environment and service
Herbert Olsen
Man oh man . . . AWESOME food and service. Hubby had 3 meat lasagna and I had a delicious calizone. Portions were huge so we took home enough for supper tomorrow night. Hubby also ordered triple chocolate cake which was HUGE. Highly recommend
Carolyn LeCroy
Top notch food and service. Menu offers excellent variety and the staff is accommodating and patient. A MUST if you’re in town. Only criticism is that the pizzas should be labeled “personal” as you will not want to share yours with anyone else. I’d recommend a particular pizza but they’re amazing.
Christopher Samal
Awesome food, great atmosphere, amazing service! Love this place.
kristen spangler
Great service and some great food. 1st time to Sackets Harbor and our first dinner was here. We had multiple pizzas and share them with our family so we could enjoy many different types.
Jason G
My friends and family went out to eat for dinner on a Wednesday night. We enjoyed wine night very much. We shared some delicious antipasto salad and pizzas. Everything was great and the service was awesome all around.
Lindsey June
I have to admit that I am biased here (I briefly worked here in 2017), but this is still the best pizza I ever had. I was a pizza cook and I can attest that the real standout qualities for the pizzas here are: Wholesome, quality ingredients and toppings; and, 2. A lot of creative pizza choices. The setting is also really neat (all of Sackets Harbor is pretty neat). I actually appeared cooking pizza in one of their TV commercials. Missing the delicious pizza!
